Your rollover size decides this, and it decides it before anything else. Below $50,000 there is no comparison to make: Augusta Precious Metals will not open the account, so Goldco is the only one of the two available to you, and only if you clear its own $25,000 threshold. Above $50,000 both are open, the ten-year fee difference between them is roughly $250, and the choice comes down to how you want to be sold to. The table sets out the figures.
This page contains affiliate links. We may earn a commission if you open an account through one of them, at no extra cost to you. It does not change the figures below or the verdict.
Augusta vs Goldco Side by Side
Figures verified 31 August 2026. Fee figures were checked against each company's current schedule, with CNBC Select as a secondary source. Augusta does not publish a standard public fee page, so its figures are the ones quoted at onboarding. Some 2026 coverage reported that Goldco had dropped its account minimum; $25,000 was still the stated figure when checked on 31 August 2026, so confirm it directly before you plan around it.
The Verdict as a Rule, Not an Opinion
Three bands cover almost everyone reading this.
Under $25,000. Neither company will open the account under its stated minimum. That is not a slight against you, it is a business decision on their side. Your options are dealers with a $2,000 to $10,000 floor, or waiting until the balance is larger.
$25,000 to $50,000. Goldco, by elimination. Augusta's $50,000 minimum removes it from the comparison entirely, and no amount of preference for Augusta's process changes that.
Above $50,000. Both are available, and the annual fee gap is small enough that it should not be your deciding factor. What separates them is process, incentive structure and buyback wording, covered below.
Ten-Year Cost in Dollars
Percentages make this look bigger than it is. Goldco with commingled storage costs $50 up front and $200 a year, roughly $2,050 over a decade. Augusta costs about $50 up front and about $225 a year, roughly $2,300 over the same period before any advertised waiver. The gap is around $250 across ten years, or about $25 a year. Goldco also charges $30 per wire transfer, which most account holders pay at least once when funding.
Segregated storage reverses that. It moves Goldco to $250 a year, or roughly $2,550 over ten years, which makes Augusta the cheaper of the two by about $250. Which company wins on fees depends entirely on which storage type you pick. Augusta advertises fee waiver tiers tied to account size, which can widen its advantage further, though the terms are not published on a standard schedule and are agreed during onboarding. A waiver is a discount funded out of the margin on the metal you buy, so treat it as a negotiating point rather than free money.
The practical takeaway is that anyone choosing between these two on annual fees alone is optimising the smallest number on the table.
The Cost That Swamps the Fee Gap
Neither company publishes what it charges over the spot price of gold, and that number is worth ten to twenty times the fee difference.
Typical 2026 premiums on IRA-eligible product run roughly 3% to 5% over spot for bars from accredited refiners and roughly 5% to 8% for American Gold Eagles and Canadian Gold Maple Leafs. On a $100,000 purchase, the difference between a 4% premium and a 7% premium is $3,000. The entire ten-year fee gap between Augusta and Goldco is $250.
So the question that actually separates them is not on any comparison page, including this one. It is: what is your price per ounce on this specific product, what is spot at this moment, and what is your buyback bid on the same product today? Ask both companies on the same day, in writing, on the same product. Our guide to negotiating gold IRA fees and dealer markups has the wording that gets a straight answer.
Process, Promotions and Buyback
Process. Augusta routes prospective customers through a one-on-one web conference with its education team before the account opens. Reviewers note this session is aimed at savers with $100,000 or more. For someone who wants context before committing six figures, that is the appeal. For someone who already knows what they want and resents a mandatory appointment, it is friction. Goldco runs a phone-based process with live chat available, which is faster and less structured.
Promotions. Goldco advertises 5% to 10% back in free silver on qualifying purchases. Augusta leans on fee waivers instead. Neither is free. Bonus metal is funded by the spread on your gold purchase, which is exactly the number neither company publishes, so a generous silver offer paired with a wide premium can cost you more than no offer at all. We ran the arithmetic in what free silver promotions really cost you.
Buyback. Goldco advertises a highest buyback price guarantee, which is a stronger public commitment than Augusta's, though "highest" is measured against the company's own pricing rather than an external benchmark. Augusta offers buyback assistance without a guaranteed price. In either case, read the actual wording in the account paperwork rather than the marketing page, and look for whether the commitment names a reference price, a timeframe, and any product exclusions. A guarantee with no reference price is a customer service promise, not a pricing floor.
Ratings. Both are reported to hold an A+ Better Business Bureau rating and a AAA Business Consumer Alliance rating, with low complaint volume relative to the industry. We could not open the BBB profiles directly at the time of writing, so treat those as attributed rather than first-hand and check them yourself before you sign.
What It Costs to Leave
Almost no comparison covers the exit, and it belongs in the decision. Moving a gold IRA from one dealer to another is a trustee-to-trustee transfer between custodians, which the IRS treats as a non-taxable event when done directly. See the IRS guidance on rollovers of retirement plan and IRA distributions for the distinction between a direct transfer and a 60-day rollover.
What it costs in practice: an account termination fee from the outgoing custodian, shipping and insurance on the metal if the depository changes, and reregistration paperwork. If you liquidate rather than transfer the metal in kind, you pay the dealer spread a second time, which is the expensive version. Expect several weeks either way. Neither company makes this impossible, and neither makes it instant.
When the Answer Is Neither
Under about $15,000, a gold IRA struggles to justify itself regardless of which company you pick. Annual costs are largely flat, so $200 a year on a $10,000 account is 2% annually before you pay a cent of markup, against 0.2% on $100,000. Add a 5% purchase premium and the account starts life meaningfully behind.
If your balance is in that range and you still want physical metal, buying bullion outside a retirement account avoids custodian and storage fees entirely, at the cost of the IRA's tax treatment. If your goal is inflation exposure rather than physical possession, the account structure question changes shape altogether. Neither Augusta nor Goldco will raise this with you, because neither is paid to.
Common Questions
Is Augusta or Goldco better for a gold IRA?
Neither is better in general. Below $50,000 Goldco is the only one available. Above $50,000, Goldco costs roughly $250 less over ten years and offers a stated buyback guarantee, while Augusta offers a more structured education process and negotiable fee waivers. The premium each quotes you over spot matters more than either point.
Does Goldco still have a minimum investment?
Its widely published minimum is $25,000, and that is what CNBC Select's profile listed when we checked on 31 August 2026. Some 2026 coverage reported the minimum being dropped. Because this changes without announcement, ask Goldco directly and get the answer in writing before you plan around it.
Which has lower fees, Augusta or Goldco?
It depends on the storage type. With commingled storage Goldco is cheaper by about $25 a year, or $250 over a decade. With segregated storage Goldco costs $250 a year against Augusta's $225, which makes Augusta cheaper by about $250 over the same period. Augusta's advertised waivers can widen that further depending on what you negotiate.
Do Augusta and Goldco use the same custodian and depository?
Not necessarily. Augusta is commonly reported to work with Equity Trust as custodian and the Delaware Depository for storage. Goldco works with several custodians and depositories depending on the account. Ask which specific custodian and which specific vault your metal will sit in, and confirm it appears on your statement.
Can I move my gold IRA from Goldco to Augusta later?
Yes, as a trustee-to-trustee transfer, which is not a taxable event. You will pay a termination fee, shipping and insurance, and the spread a second time if you sell rather than transfer the metal in kind. It is a correction, not a free do-over.
Which is better for a rollover under $25,000?
Neither. Look at dealers with a $2,000 to $10,000 floor, and read our comparison of the major gold IRA companies by minimum and fees to see which ones will actually take the account.
The Short Version
Let your rollover size make the first cut. Under $25,000 the answer is neither. Between $25,000 and $50,000 it is Goldco by elimination. Above $50,000 it is a preference question, not a cost question, because $250 over ten years will not decide your outcome. Get a written per-ounce quote and a same-day buyback bid from both, on the same product, and let that number choose. Our full Goldco review and the questions to ask before you sign are worth reading before either call.
